Insight

Challenging the status quo to deliver innovation in DC pensions

Person walking on a rope from one high-rise building to other

Our recent DC roundtable brought together senior leaders and asset owners to explore the evolving role of fixed income in defined contribution (DC) pensions. Set against a backdrop of macroeconomic uncertainty, regulatory reform, and shifting member expectations, the discussion revealed a sector in transition - one that is embracing innovation, rethinking traditional allocations, and striving to deliver better outcomes across the member journey. We had significant representation from the DC market, with several hundred million in DC assets across People’s Pension, Scottish Widows, Standard Life/Phoenix Group, Smart, and NatWest Cushon.

Introduction: Adding certainty around uncertainty

Rob Waldner, Head of IFI Strategy and Macro Research, opened the session with a macroeconomic overview that captured the complexity of the current environment. US growth is expected to slow, driven by a tightening labour market and persistent inflation. Interest rates are likely to remain elevated, and the US dollar is facing medium-term weakness as global investors diversify away from US assets. Fiscal concerns, including a growing deficit now exceeding 6% of GDP, are adding to the uncertainty.

Yet amid this turbulence, fixed income has emerged as a resilient and attractive asset class. Emerging market local currency bonds have performed particularly well, with notable gains since 20231, and global bonds are drawing renewed interest. For active managers, this is an opportunity-rich environment, one that could reward agility, diversification, and a willingness to look beyond traditional allocations.

The roundtable set out to explore how fixed income can be better deployed across the DC landscape, not just as a late-stage de-risking tool, but as a strategic allocation throughout the member journey.

Theme 1: Evolving Market Dynamics and Regulatory Changes

Fixed income has re-emerged as a compelling asset class, with emerging market local currency bonds and global bonds performing strongly. For active managers, the current regime offers opportunities particularly in global markets where valuations, yield curves, and currency dynamics are creating space for differentiated returns.

Regulatory reform is reshaping the DC landscape. The UK is positioning itself as a leader in pension innovation, with initiatives like the Mansion House Accord and the FCA’s targeted support framework pushing schemes to modernise. However, as several participants noted, regulatory change is outpacing behavioural change. While the frameworks are evolving, many schemes are still slow to adapt, particularly when it comes to diversifying away from traditional US-centric exposures.

Currency hedging emerged as a key area of debate. With the dollar weakening and portfolios becoming more globally diversified, the need for dynamic, flexible hedging strategies is growing. It could be beneficial to hold some currency exposure within portfolios due to its diversification benefits. One attendee noted, currency management will be “huge going forward,” especially as portfolios incorporate more private market assets.

Theme 2: Reframing Fixed Income in the Member Journey

A central theme of the roundtable was the need to rethink how fixed income is deployed across the DC member journey. Historically it was viewed as a de-risking tool for those nearing retirement, fixed income is now being reconsidered as a strategic allocation throughout the journey.

Participants agreed that fixed income plays a vital role, but its form and function must evolve. In the early stages of the journey, liquid income-generating assets provided flexibility and stability. As members move closer to retirement, illiquid assets such as private credit offer diversification and the potential for enhanced returns through the illiquidity premium.

Private credit is gaining traction. Once confined to direct lending, the opportunity set has broadened significantly and is now being used to increase the resilience of portfolios. Participants highlighted the importance of blending these strategies to manage liquidity while still capturing upside potential.

The challenge lies in balancing liquidity needs with return objectives. Discussions revealed how semi-liquid structures are becoming increasingly attractive. They offer diversification without locking members in. This flexibility is essential in a world where members may need access to their funds at different points in their journey.

With public markets shrinking and private markets expanding, schemes are looking to build diverse alternatives buckets that include structured credit, private debt, and other non-traditional assets. The goal is to add capability, not complexity, ensuring that portfolios remain explainable and aligned with member outcomes.

Theme 3: Engagement and a Solutions Mindset

While investment strategy was front and centre, the conversation repeatedly returned to the issue of member engagement. Despite advances in digital tools and mobile platforms, many members remain disengaged particularly at critical decision points. The 2022 gilt crisis was cited as a moment when better engagement could have made a meaningful difference.

We agreed that engagement must be proactive, educational, and tailored. It’s not enough to communicate investment decisions, members need to understand them. As one attendee put it, “we want to make sure every line is explainable to clients.” This means simplifying complex concepts like CLOs and private credit, and helping members see the long-term value of their pensions.

Technology is playing a key role in bridging this gap. From mobile apps to targeted support, digital transformation is making it easier for members to manage their pensions. However, the real challenge is encouraging long-term thinking and helping members see their pension as a journey, not just a pot.

A solutions mindset is essential. Rather than focusing on individual asset classes or regulatory constraints, schemes must think holistically, building portfolios that solve for investment risk, regulatory compliance, and member needs simultaneously.

Conclusion: A sector moving forward together

The roundtable closed with a shared sense of purpose. While each provider is on a different path, the direction is clear: build balanced, flexible portfolios that deliver value across the entire member journey. This means embracing innovation, rethinking traditional allocations, and putting member outcomes at the heart of every decision.

The industry is on a journey to transition portfolios and align with new expectations. The challenge is significant but so is the opportunity. With the right partnerships, strategies, and mindset, the DC sector can rise to meet it.

Defined contribution pensions

We are dedicated to delivering customised DC investment solutions and strategies, thought-provoking insights and tools, and responsive client service to support our shared goal: helping members achieve a comfortable retirement.

Learn more
  • Footnotes

    Source: J.P. Morgan and ICE Data Indices as of 13.05.2025.

    Investment risks

    The value of investments and any income will fluctuate (this may partly be the result of exchange rate fluctuations) and investors may not get back the full amount invested.

    Important information

    Data as at 26.06.25, unless otherwise stated. This is marketing material and not financial advice. It is not intended as a recommendation to buy or sell any particular asset class, security or strategy. Regulatory requirements that require impartiality of investment/investment strategy recommendations are therefore not applicable nor are any prohibitions to trade before publication. Views and opinions are based on current market conditions and are subject to change.

    EMEA4640260